I love fragments. So much! Fragments audition for my blog. They stand, waiting patiently on the side of the desk. Hopeful. Frisky. Nonchalant. Nervous. Indifferent. I see them there, primping, straightening out their letters, standing all alone, moving away when another word tries to be polite and make small talk. Sometimes I just abandon them, tell them I don’t need them, but they grin because they know I’m lying. They know.
Surprise! One will show up.
Here is
another rule: Show, don’t tell. My very disheveled 9th grade
English teacher would run around the classroom, tapping an imaginary ruler in
her hand, then she would cry out, “Show, don’t tell!” I had no idea what she was talking about. I didn’t want to look stupid though, by
asking the question that the other 99% of the students already knew the answer
to, so I would just nod-nod-nod. Of
course, of course, Mrs. Bowles (with your unflattering bowl cut hairstyle), of course! Show, don’t tell! I get it!
I didn’t
really get it. Not then.
Twenty years
later, I had my Oprah Winfrey lightbulb moment when I was explaining to my younger
cousin my definition of good writing.
“Elyse, you should
say, ‘I forgot my coat and it began to snow,’ not ‘I am cold.’ You write, ‘The neighbors had a party and blared
heavy metal through the paper-thin walls until 3 AM, and of course I had to be
up at 6 for work. No pot of coffee is
large enough for me today,’ not ‘I’m tired.’
You write the situation without spelling it out for the reader, you let
them make the connections, do the translations, for themselves.”
Wait—this was what Mrs. Bowles must’ve meant! Egads!
Now I felt
like Christopher Columbus when he discovered President Lincoln lied about being
shot.
Huh?
Yeah,
there’s another one of my rules: don’t
do the expected thing. Avoid
clichés. Don’t say, “Raining cats and
dogs” (unless you are a cartoonist and you’re going to provide the visual—then
by all means!). Don’t type “It was
pouring outside.” Find a new, creative
way to say it. How about, “The sky
growled, it seemed the black clouds were angry at me personally, and then they
released their violent gray pellets of water directed maliciously at my
pristine new silk dress. Yes, the one
with the rainbow ribbon at the hem. The
irony was not lost on me.” How much more interesting than the pedestrian “cats and dogs.” The reader has read cats and dogs a million gazillion eleventy billion times,
And people
don’t like to read more than 500 words.
So stop there.
MOV
Great, entertaining post about writing. I adore fragments as well. I also love to start sentences with And and But. Annoying to some. A pleasure to me!!!
ReplyDeleteMe too! But not all the time.
DeleteI don't use rules when writing, other than to not maul the English language too badly. You won't catch me saying "there is fewer peanut butter in the jar cause Mikey ate it". Fragments are good. Sometimes. And if I concentrate and get to 501 words, I'll just end it like "it was raining cats and...." ":))
DeleteGREAT post MOV.
Thank you, Gina!
DeleteAnd Youngman!
But don't forget Raymond! Thanks to all of you. :)
best,
MOV
where have you been, Véronique?????
ReplyDeleteWait til you read my post for tomorrow. I definitely do weird stuff in that one, as far as "rules" go.
ReplyDeleteI did read it-- great job!
DeleteSplendide. Magnifique. Six years of French tumbled out of my mouth as two French fragments. Mon Dieu.
ReplyDeleteSusan
http://travelbug-susan.blogspot.com
Oh, those French words. They make me swoon.
DeleteGreat post. Entertaining but also had some really helpful tips in it. Especially the "show don't tell"! (Bozo - had to change my name)
ReplyDeleteThank you, Lady in Red!
DeleteI was here, just humbled by all your blogger followers.
ReplyDeleteTerrific! Great advice.
ReplyDelete"He feels like he was stampeded by a wild herd of clichés, ugly ones with rabies and matted fur." -- That cracked me up! Such a crazy mental image I have now.
Thank you, Couse. You seem to always pick the line that was my favorite, too. ;)
DeleteThe words, humbled by the twisted fates of billions before them, refuse capture. Resigned to their plight, they bubble just near the surface, tantalizing the tongue, yet evading the very air that gives them life.
ReplyDeleteOr, I'm speechless.
Well done.
show off. ;)
DeleteI love this! You have given me renewed inspiration with my newly-begun WIP! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteAh! Good! I'm glad.
DeleteI love this so much. Spot on and wonderful and funny. But... but... but... I think a working knowledge of the rules gives us liberty to break them, no? It sometimes is the difference between creative writing and illiterate writing? Or am I just a fusty writing snob? I never can tell. Regardless, this is a great piece.
ReplyDeleteHi Tangled Lou,
DeleteI agree. A fragment? Or purpose? Yes. A fragment that. Was obviously an accident and literally makes no. Sense whatsoever, well that looks dumb.
Thanks for commenting!
I break every one of these every single day or minute. And every second. When pigs fly or when it is raining cats and dogs I won't.
ReplyDeleteOr will I?
You have most undoubtedly conformed to my great expectations of injecting sheer brilliance into the heart of every post you magically cast onto the internet world while you weave tales of your paralyzing knowledge and daily duties as a domesticated servant to the wee little people you commonly refer to as "Tall" and "Short."
That means "This is great!"
And this means ditto to what CYW said. "This is great" and funny too. Rules are meant to be pushed to the limit, stretched, transmogrified and diddled endlessly. That's the fun part, doing it with style as MOV does. CYW, you're not so bad at it yourself....eh. ":) ~R
DeleteTracie, I am liking the "magically" part. No one ever called the way I write "magical." THANKS!!
DeleteRaymond, I appreciate your very kind words!!
Love this! :D
ReplyDeletethanks!
DeleteThis is a pretty good summary of rules. I use most of these, and I looove fragments.
ReplyDeleteThe one rule I don't use is the 500 words - I hadn't even thought about that until now. Went back and checked my latest piece, and apparently it's 2,500.
Whoops.
That's okay. I read it in its entirety.
DeleteAsh-Matic, You made her read it FIVE times? and she did not break up with you? On another note, SO glad your dissertation is over and you can get back to blogging!!!!!! The Blogoverse missed you!
DeleteErica, It was worth the 2500 words, eh?
I'm a huge fan of sentences that start with And and But. And also irony. I find that - as I improve at blog-writing - I get worse at writing other stuff!
ReplyDeleteOoooh, Irony is my middle name! Or Ophelia. The birth certificate might say Ophelia.
DeleteI break every rule taught by an English teacher. I blog for a different reason though, mine is a form of therapy. I come to blogs like yours to learn =)
ReplyDeleteThank you, Elsie. That is really sweet of you to say. (*note to self: send Elsie flowers)
DeleteMy cousin was working on a college essay this year and her professor told her that she needed to show not tell, basically. I'm going to send her this post.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Erica! (*note to self, send Erica flowers)
DeleteCan I put excerpts from this on the top of a creative writing assignment for my Grade 11 English class? I'll reference your blog, of course. Let me know!
ReplyDeleteYES! I am so flattered. :) I wrote another piece a while back that you might also like for your students, here is the link:
Deletehttp://mothersofbrothersblog.blogspot.com/2011/02/322-it-is-time-for-some-punctuation.html
Hope your students are inspired!
best,
MOV
That was amazingness encircling a bowl of awesomesauce. Perfection.
ReplyDelete~The G is Silent
Thanks, Kim! Not sure what a bowl of awesomesauce is, but if it has caffeine in it, I am totally onboard.
DeleteThank you for the nice compliment! (*note to self, flower bill is getting expensive)
Stop picking on me.
ReplyDeletexoxo Favorite Co-Author
You are so silly. :)
DeleteI like to do this...those periods, right there...I don't remember learning about them in grammatical education sessions, but I like them. They have replaced - as my fave incorrectly made up punctuation! I hope this falls under the umbrella of the rules you have laid out for us...please!
ReplyDeleteHey Andrea,
DeleteFYI, I had an editor correct me on those ellipsis. I know I use them wrong all the time.......... (that was wrong, so don't copy me there!)
The correct way to use them is this: You write your words, then ... there are three little dots separated with a space on either side. If you are finishing your sentence with them, then four dots (one is the final period) to look like this ....
If the ellipsis are inside of quotes, do this: "I left the store early, thinking he might already be home ..." (that last space went away because we are inside of quotation marks).
Hope that helps! If not, come back tomorrow ....
best,
MOV
Uh-oh, now I will feel guilty for using them incorrectly...because I think I still might!
DeleteHi! I'm new to your blog. I love this post. I think it's fun to make up your rules. I look forward to reading more your blog! :)
ReplyDeleteHi Missy! Welcome! I am glad you are here. :)
DeleteLove, love love this advice.
ReplyDelete